Our Story
A Bay Area pizza legend since 1961
“The Pizza with the Secret”
When Nunzio Cicero left Niagara Falls, New York for California in the early 1960s, he carried something more valuable than gold — a secret pizza crust recipe that would make him a Silicon Valley legend. His New York-style thin, foldable pies, baked on canola oil in metal pans, were unlike anything the Bay Area had ever tasted.
Our History
The Beginning
Nunzio Cicero opens his first pizzeria in Old Cupertino at Stevens Creek & DeAnza Blvd. Originally named "Pee-Wee's Pizza," then "Coppola's," before becoming Cicero's. He brings his legendary crust recipe from Niagara Falls, New York.
A Bay Area Institution
Cicero's becomes a beloved gathering place for families across Silicon Valley. When the original Cupertino location is redeveloped, the restaurant moves to Stevens Creek & Blaney Ave, continuing to serve loyal customers.
End of an Era
The Stevens Creek location closes in the summer. Sadly, founder Nunzio Cicero passes away at 87, just one month later. The Bay Area fears they've lost their favorite pizzeria forever.
A Family Legacy Continues
Nunzio's son-in-law Bob LaVerdi and grandson Rik Jones reopen Cicero's Pizza at its current home on 6138 Bollinger Road in San Jose, keeping the original recipes and traditions alive.
Still the Best-Kept Secret
Over 60 years later, Cicero's continues to serve the same legendary New York-style thin, foldable pies. With 4.4 stars and 1,235+ reviews on Yelp, the secret is out — but the recipe stays secret.
What Makes Cicero's Special
The Secret Recipe
Our crust recipe came straight from Niagara Falls, NY with founder Nunzio Cicero. It's been the same for over 60 years — and we're not changing it.
NY-Style, Done Right
Thin, foldable pies baked on canola oil in metal pans. If you know real New York pizza, you'll feel right at home.
Family Legacy
Three generations of the Cicero family have kept this tradition alive — from Nunzio to his son-in-law Bob LaVerdi and grandson Rik Jones.
Famous Fans
Steve Wozniak's family are long-time customers — you can see photos on our wall. We've been featured on PBS "Check, Please! Bay Area" too.
Community Roots
From Old Cupertino to Bollinger Road, we've been part of the Silicon Valley community for over six decades.
Rave Reviews
4.4 stars and 1,235+ reviews on Yelp with 380+ photos. Our customers speak for themselves.
In the Press
PBS
Check, Please! Bay Area
Featured as one of the Bay Area's must-visit pizza spots on the popular PBS dining show.
Mercury News
Bay Area Landmark
Covered as a beloved Bay Area institution with deep roots in Silicon Valley history.
Yelp
4.4 Stars · 1,235+ Reviews
Consistently top-rated with hundreds of photos from happy customers.
Come Taste the Secret
Visit us at 6138 Bollinger Road, San Jose, or call to order.